#Fracking rally in #Salford, #Manchester on Sun 26th Jan – ideas to make it more effective!

There was a solidarity rally at Barton Moss on Sunday 12th January. Another has been called for this coming Sunday, 26th January.  Solidarity is good, but solidarity and movement-building is even better.  This below is the tidied-up text of an email I sent to someone involved in one of the campaigning groups involved. It’s about how another such day could be more effective. That person responded very positively, and perhaps others will too? #fingerscrossed.

Analysis of the rally today.
[see the end of the post for the stuff I wrote as preamble]
The rally, in my opinion, was an opportunity to increase the “logistics” of the movement.

Structure of the day
At the outset it would have been great to have had five or ten people in “official” clothing (even if it was just a bib over the top of coats – it’s way too cold for getting about in t-shirts!) handing out a “welcome to the rally” sheet.

This could include
a) thanks for coming
b) how you can help the campaign (money, letters to MPs/papers etc)
c) a list of skills/equipment that the campaign would like
d) a phone number for what to do if it kicks off and the police decide to arrest people (yes, I know it didn’t happen today, but including this sort of information on leaflets is worth it)
It also would need a bit on why the camp exists, who iGas are, what the campaign thinks the next flashpoint(s) will be.

At the outset as well as thanking people for coming

  • encourage them to speak to other people whom they know slightly or not at all
  • encourage them to smile and wave at the cars (though people did this already)
  • make it repeatedly and crystal clear that their involvement is wanted for the Long Haul; that they have skills and knowledge and resources that are vital to the struggle

During the march and at the rallying point, have “official” people circulating with A5 papers on clipboards. These sheets of A5 give people a space to write their name, their email address and perhaps a tick list of skills that they might have.

Then you can email all the people who came to personally thank them.
Ask everyone to join the facebook groups. Have a hashtag.
Ask people to make films about why fracking is a bad idea and put them up on youtube.
Ask them to blog
Ask them to leave supportive comments on the MEN articles

At the rallying point.
Start with a song.
Keep. The. Speeches. To. A. Minimum! (but that’s just me. I hate the damn things. Most people aren’t listening, and what is being said is worthy, predictable and largely uninspiring…)
Have someone who gets everyone turning and talking to a stranger. The bosses want us to be isolated. We need to learn to connect with each other. [link to my Alexandra Park speech]
You could even get us into small (5 or 6 people) brain-storming groups for ten minutes. Provide paper and a pen and ask groups to come up with answers to questions like “what can we learn from past protest camps?”, “what do our work colleagues/casual acquaintances not understand about fracking/what bits of pro-fracking propaganda have gained traction”, “besides camps and rallies and petitions, how else can we convert people’s anger into political power?” Then collect the paper, type them up and put them on the website.  (At the very least, the act of getting into small groups introduces people to strangers, and gets them thinking more strategically.)

Finish with a song, or a cheer or something, before people head down to the camp itself.

I have a few skills (writing, film-making, being interviewed on radio, blogging, writing letters to the newspaper). At no point today was it at all clear to me if/how any of those skills were wanted and how they could be harnessed. At no point did I hear that my skills were wanted, or that if I joined, I would learn new skills. (And yes, this rally wasn’t about me. But it was, surely, about getting people more involved?)

I hope the campaign goes from strength to strength. I hope that the next rally innovates a bit more!

Marc Hudson

Further Reading

“rallies and marches are not a progression of the great non-violent direct action movements of the past. They are exactly what they sound like: a very limited and rather banal aspect of a much more interesting and dynamic manifestation of global historic and modern day social change…”


The preamble that I’ve relegated to here

First thing – congratulations on the event, and the ongoing campaign, and I would like to know how I can help further. (Getting there is problematic for me)

The main purpose of the rally seems to have been to raise morale among the campaigners (and especially the campers), with a secondary aim of getting some positive press (though this is of course fraught).

I am not qualified to speak to the morale question – though the people I spoke to mostly seemed to have a good time there. (I did not, but I realise I have become utterly cynical about these sorts of events, so I am not a reliable barometer).

On the press thing – well, the BBC story on their website was neutral, at least until it reported the clever smear from a few days ago. We will have to wait and see what/if the MEN says. I think we may overestimate the importance of the MEN, tbh.

What I want to focus on, however, is the missed opportunities from today’s event – not so much what did happen, but what didn’t happen but could have happened.

I know that some of this will be taken as a criticism. And I know that we humans tend to get very defensive and deaf when we perceive ourselves to being criticised/attacked. There’s not a lot I can do about that, other than ask that people try to understand that I am writing this in the hope that “we” – those actively opposed to the unfolding insanity – can get better at the way we do things.

About manchesterclimatemonthly

Was print format from 2012 to 13. Now web only. All things climate and resilience in (Greater) Manchester.
This entry was posted in Campaign Update. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to #Fracking rally in #Salford, #Manchester on Sun 26th Jan – ideas to make it more effective!

  1. gille liath says:

    I think I’m beginning to see where you’re going with this. Does it concern you that some people may be concerned about climate change and against fracking, but not want to be part of a ‘movement’, with song-singing, hugging etc? They may just not see themselves as that kind of people. Isn’t the most important thing to convey the message that these issues are for everyone, not just part of a fringe lifestyle choice? I genuinely think there’s a danger of alienating the mainstream public, who tend to look at this sort of thing (as someone said to me recently) as ‘rentamob’.

  2. No, it doesn’t concern me. Anyone who doesn’t like song-singing and hugging is clearly a bourgeois revisionist capitalist lickspittle running dog who will be first against the wall come the revolution… (irony)

    Am very familiar with the “rentamob” comment. What always amuses me is that the basic things that people take for granted – like the vote, education, birth control, health and safety etc etc – were NOT granted by our lords and masters in a fit of paternalism. They were FOUGHT for, by the “rentamobs” of yesteryear. Be they the suffragists, or the slave trade abolitionists, the trade unionists (Tolpuddle Martyrs etc etc etc), Chartists. It’s always easy to sneer (I am not saying you are, but the term ‘rentamob’ is) at people who think and dress differently. But those people are, sadly, all that stands between us and armageddon.
    So I want THEM to do a better job of connecting with each other, increasing their effectiveness. And I want everyone else to be able to contribute to the movement too, which is why I keep banging on about “legitimate peripheral participation.”
    And leaving comments on websites doesn’t count. Other than these comments from the sidelines, Gille, what do you actually DO about the crises you are so aware of? I know that may sound like an attack, but it is actually asked more of a genuine curiosity.

    • gille liath says:

      I’m thinking of forming a drama group, to express them in the form of mime. 😉

      Seriously, and as I think your question was asked in a friendly spirit, I’ll answer: I’m more of a letter-writer/ lobbier / petitioner etc. I don’t really have either the opportunity or the temperament for direct action; I’m the kind who’s uncomfortable walking on the grass. But I’d also say: it’s easy enough to find yourself an activity, but whether it does anything to improve things is another matter. And as with any serious problem, it’s (of course) always easier to say what shouldn’t be done than what should. My ‘comments from the sidelines’ here are always intended to take that as read.

      I don’t dispute the need for protest, though; it’s the whole ‘performing arts’ side of it I’m not sure about. There’s a perception that some people protest about everything, because in some sense they enjoy it / get affirmation from it. I don’t think that perception is entirely unjustified, and anything that gives the ‘movement’ a flaky, hippy image tends to reinforce it. If any ordinary ‘square’ person is thinking of standing between us and Armageddon, it puts them off.

  3. Via facebook –

    Please contact the Conservative and Liberal Democrats by the FREEPOST ADDRESSES below (no stamp is needed), and tell them you want Britain to be FRACK FREE…

    Then please share this Project and invite other people to it, it will only cost you a few minutes of your time to help secure a FRACK FREE FUTURE for yourself, your loved ones and many happier generations to come…

    If you could get everybody in your household to write individually to both parties, it is our Country after all, we all should have an equal say, if you have children then this would be a great letter for them to write, to get them involved in politics and environmental issues, if they are not already.

    The FREEPOST addresses are as follows :-

    The Conservative Party
    30 Millbank
    SW1P 4DP

    Liberal Democrats
    M20 5NF
    Apparently this is the incorrect address and you need to write to Ed Davey. So says John Leech’s lead caseworker on 15th April 2014.


    Please save the above addresses in your phone or elsewhere so you always have them at hand to give to others, thank you very much in advance…

  4. HB says:

    a leaflet would be great on sunday if someone – sadly not me – has had time and resources for that. but i like speeches! and i don’t like writing to MPs. i’d say what makes for effective protest is pretty debatable and can’t be reduced to a formula – learn from experience, sure, but people have different experiences…

    • It certainly can’t be reduced for a formula, but some things are less wrong than others.
      “Effective” for me is more-than-felt-good-on-the-day. It’s about strengthening our movements and networks. The rally I went to, on the 12th, didn’t do that as well as it could have, in the opinion of me and other people!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s