What the Pennines could be… a personal view by Cllr David Ellison

This is a manifesto to create a natural environment from the Southern Pennines to the Scottish border.
peninesWe live in a densely populated country , but those of us living in cities feel cut off from wild environments. Manchester is fortunate to be surrounded by the Pennines on two sides and I often spend at least part of every day looking longingly at the not-so-distant hills. The smooth round hills of the Pennines are not truly wild in any real sense though. They look that way after centuries of stripping down the native forests and then continual over-gazing by animals released onto the land by human activity and now supported by heavy farming subsidies to keep marginal land in production.
The higher moors are kept clear of trees by constant burning to create shooting ranges and the extreme acidic environment created by air pollution from our old industrial  environment. Only the highest mountains in the UK are above the natural tree-line.

I’ve been inspired to write this by my regular walks over the southern Pennines and further afield in Wales , The Lake District and Scotland. I’ve been thinking about this for long time and argued with people about the need to bring back real wild country, but it has been brought in to sharp relief by the publication of George Monbiot’s recent book “Feral.” All that really needs to be done to create a natural environment of forest and high moorland is benign removal of subsidy for marginal sheep farming and the fencing in of those areas we want to turn to forest to protect them from the ravages of stray sheep, deer and rabbits. Nature will do the rest and within a generation the southern Pennines will become a natural forest, creating huge potential benefits as a store house of atmospheric carbon, vastly increasing the natural habitats of all our native species of plants and animals  and providing a richer environment with forestry, fishing and natural tourism from surrounding cities replacing many times over the few jobs that sheep farming currently supports.

If we want to speed the process up we could encourage this process by starting to plant native trees on the lower slopes and on the edges of river valleys and then bringing back species such as otters and beavers.   I am not arguing for the loss of the high heather moors here; these could continue to managed as they are today to encourage heather and preserve the wide sweeping views.

All that is required is concerted action to take marginal land in the Pennine chain out of subsidized sheep farming and allow forests to develop and grow as they once did before humans came and removed them. With help from public bodies, land owners and ordinary people this vision could be realized within our life times and would be one legacy our generation of post-war consumers could leave to our children.

Councillor David Ellison
Labour Member Didsbury West Ward
Manchester City Council

Writing from a personal view of the world

About manchesterclimatemonthly

Was print format from 2012 to 13. Now web only. All things climate and resilience in (Greater) Manchester.
This entry was posted in Biodiversity and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to What the Pennines could be… a personal view by Cllr David Ellison

  1. Hi Marc,

    For some reason, I am not able to leave any comments on any of your posts. I do not know if it is a problem with my browser, server or windows 7. But I agree with David, but with the exception that it is the grouse moors that should be reforested first. The National Trust has carried out some minor re-planting, but I have not been up there to see how that has progressed. With Dave Bishop’s article, I agree that a number of NGO’s are basically not ‘fit-for-purpose’. And that the council and property developers should stop felling perfectly healthy trees. A mature Oak can support a hundred different species withing it’s micro-environment. And the council should stop it’s program of planting non-native trees, such as Magnolias. These do not support any local biodiversity, and are planted in pavements with no room for their roots to expand. There is a need to plant more trees, for various environmental reason and human well-being. But they have to be native trees (grown natively) but planted appropriately.


    On Mon, 29 Jul 2013 12:16:31 +0000

  2. james says:

    I’d definately support this. Other than the obvious and exciting improvements this would make to our national landscape, hillside sheep farming is largely unprofitable and survives only on considerable government subsidy. Wouldn’t it be more beneficial to pay those same landowners to manage new forestry. England currently has 8% forest as oposed to 30% in france and germany. The pennines peak district and lake district being reforested would bring us more in line with other countries in this respect.

  3. steph says:

    I agree just let it return to its former state and stop over grazing and erosion

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s