Investing in Nature? Or pretzelled people hearing pretzel logic in #Manchester… #climate #redemptionrituals

The format of a meeting always tells you a lot about the ideology of its organisers, and what they are looking to achieve (whether they can admit that – even to themselves – or not).  MCFly editor Marc Hudson gets all philosophical and “meta” about the recent “Investing in Nature” seminar. (see Richard Leese’s welcoming address here).

In the Bad Old Days of Industrial Capitalism, where nature was not respected, venerated and Valued, then we would have been sat in rows, listening to the various big cheeses at the front telling us that while there were some problems, everything would be alright as long as the current system was refined and tweaked.

badolddaysIn the New Collaborative Days of post-Industrial Capitalism, where nature is most definitely being Valued, we sit… at round tables, with some of us having therefore to twist around on our seats to listen to the various big cheeses at the front telling us that while there are some problems, everything will be alright as long as the current system is refined and tweaked.

We have swapped a system that was at least honest about who talked and who listened for one which is uncomfortable for some, who have to pretzel themselves in order to fit, but with the same underlying result. But it LOOKS better, and that, after all, is the important thing…  This is – like the meeting of the Airports Commission in the neighbouring room of the town hall a couple of months previously – nowt more than a redemption ritual.
I didn’t stick around for the “interaction” bit, but let’s just say this – the event ran for 2 and a half hours. There was a few minutes for questions. I asked “How is ‘biodiversity offsetting’ going to be different from carbon trading. I was told – in essence ‘that was intangible. This is local. Trust us.”

Hmm. Foundation, anyone?

The next question was even better – will we see a reversal of the trend of accelerating loss of biodiversity. The panelists waffled and said things like “hope to”.
Very very VERY unconvincing.

The medium is the message. There was only to be 25 minutes in the two and a half hours where we were supposed to ‘critically respond.’ After time for introductions on our tables, that presumably left closer to 15 minutes. And given that those in attendance are overwhelmingly in need of the good graces of our Lords and Masters, it seems vanishingly unlikely that anyone was going to say “this is nonsense.”

No – what will emerge, even if it’s not what the organisers tell themselves they want – is a timid rubber stamp. (See below for what happens if the rubber stamp bounces…)

The truth of the matter is this – the collapse of biodiversity is accelerating. Our “market mechanisms” will be every bit as successful at slowing the trend as they have been at slowing the increase in our carbon emissions.

employeesrevoltfinal Here’s a re-paste of a bit I wrote at the end of the Airports Commission blog post –

MCFly says:
These events are rituals. They are rituals of safety, rituals of redemption. People attend/participate/lend their good names to the process because, well, that’s just what people of their social class do. And they want to nudge the policies of the State in one direction or another. While, understandably, paying their mortgages.

All perfectly “reasonable,” and a theoretical improvement on the bad old days when policy discussions were held Behind Closed Doors.

But you can have a Reasonable Ritual that is totally inadequate to the scale of the problem.


About manchesterclimatemonthly

Was print format from 2012 to 13. Now web only. All things climate and resilience in (Greater) Manchester.
This entry was posted in Adaptation, Biodiversity, Climate Change Action Plan, GM Climate Strategy, Low Carbon Hub, Manchester City Council. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Investing in Nature? Or pretzelled people hearing pretzel logic in #Manchester… #climate #redemptionrituals

  1. There were those of us, who put forward reasons why the bio-diverse Birley Fields, Hulme, should not be built on as planned by Manchester Metropolitan University. All the evidence those opposed to the development, including scientific studies showing the benefits of green spaces in urban settings. We also referred to the councils own report, into the lack of available green space in Hulme. All our objections were rejected, with Councillor for the Environment Nigel Murphy even denying a park existed there, during the time of the Crescents.
    Then, there were those of us, who objected to the building of artificial soccer pitches on Heaton Park. Again, the objectors were ignored, and the council stating were the soccer pitches were to be sited. Was not of much natural value, being a grassed area, and nothing but a dog’s toilet. And recently, we have had the chain-saw massacre of Alexandra Park, to supposedly restore it to it Victorian Heritage. The Victorians planted the trees there, for future generations to benefit from, not for a future council to just fell them.
    This council is so obsessed in grand gestures, that are in reality, meaningless and with pleasing big business. It will not listen to reason or to the wishes of the majority of residents, who are not classed as ‘stake-holders’, in the council’s decision process. There are those, who claim to be ‘green’ and to be speaking for the community, who will back the council’s decisions up. And it is they who are the usual suspects, not those opposing the council’s badly thought out plans.

  2. An academic sent me these quotes in relation to this post – both excellent.

    Procedure confers legitimacy.
    -Jack Straw

    Failing Tao, man resorts to Virtue.
    Failing Virtue, man resorts to humanity.
    Failing humanity, man resorts to morality.
    Failing morality, man resorts to ceremony.
    Now, ceremony is the merest husk of faith and loyalty;
    It is the beginning of all confusion and disorder.

    -Lao-Tzu, Tao Teh Ching

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s