Finance Scrutiny Committee WON’T have promised report on £14.5m Clean City Fund

UPDATE 25th Sept 2014:  You will not BELIEVE the video that I put up later tonight.  Finance Scrutiny Committee DID have two officers and an Executive Member in front of them today.  With a brief report, circulated that morning that did not address their concerns. To say they were “not happy” is an understatement. Watch. This. Space.

Last month MCFly declared victory on  getting some sort of reckoning of the £14.5m “Clean City Fund”, set up with a windfall from the Airport. That declaration was premature.  The Finance Scrutiny Committee agenda for the morning of Thursday 25th September is below.  If you can spot the item, let me know.


At the August meeting (link here to video evidence and a transcript) it seemed to be agreed that the politicians in charge of the Fund – Rosa Battle and Bernard Priest – would be called to the committee, along with the head of communications, Sara Todd.

There were some basic questions that citizens and councillors have been asking for months;

– what money has been spent?
– what is the nature of the ‘review’ of the fund that has been undertaken?
– why has the instruction of the Finance Scrutiny Committee in June that a public accounting of spending be made STILL not been acted upon.

After the August meeting the chair of the committee was asked if a written report was expected.   His reply was that he was “hoping for a written report at the next meeting.”

Last week, having noticed the absence of an agenda item on the £14.5m Fund, I had an email exchange with the chair of the Finance Scrutiny Committee.
I’ll quote from myself (from Friday morning) –

Hi Carl,

thanks again for your reply.

I consider myself to be a relatively competent observer of council affairs.  I am probably the only member of the public who has attended all six scrutiny committees.
Right now, I feel like I am running in treacle, or drowning in it.
I have read this paragraph many times –
“The transcript you have listed below was also from the overview report and would have been sent as a written response, only the committee wasn’t happy with what was sent, therefore, I  have asked further clarity, and as the chair I have asked the aforementioned to attend to elaborate on item c in the  overview report which as previously mentioned “items for information”.”

– but cannot make head nor tail of it. I must be thicker than I feared.

a) Precisely *when* on the September agenda will this discussion of the £14.5m Clean and Green Fund take place?  Will it be at the very end in the “items for information”?  Does this therefore mean that members of the public cannot ask questions?
b) If that is the case, why isn’t this a specific separate item on the agenda?
c) When will the written report (see our previous email exchange) be circulated to the committee members and to members of the public?  Or will there not be a written report in advance of the meeting?

And again, where is the additional information about what has been spent that Councillor Lanchbury pressed for?

Yours with fingers crossed and brow furrowed

There was no reply to this email, so I repeated the questions on Monday morning.

Still no reply.

This is how democracy and transparency is done in this city. Am I the only person surprised, saddened or angry about it?

About manchesterclimatemonthly

Was print format from 2012 to 13. Now web only. All things climate and resilience in (Greater) Manchester.
This entry was posted in Democratic deficit, Manchester City Council. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Finance Scrutiny Committee WON’T have promised report on £14.5m Clean City Fund

  1. Yes we have been banging our heads against a very thick wall, where Manchester City Council’s accounts are concerned. I actually learnt more from Trafford Council’s accounts about certain issues concerning Manchester City Council’s accounts. Even employees of Manchester City Council would like more openness about the accounts, you would of thought the unions would be putting more pressure on Manchester City Council?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s