You can see more details about this here –
Hat-tip to the Ferret for sending me this from that beacon of sanity and consistency, the Gaurdian.
In 2012 Manchester City Council aimed for a 10% reduction in its own emissions. In July 2013 it claimed a 7% reduction. It was able to do this because responsibility for traffic lights moved from its books. Looking at everything else (buildings, transport) emissions went … UP by 1.8%.
So, building on that extremely strong base, the Council’s bureaucrats have proposed a series of actions to help them hit a new “7%” target. You can see the complete list here. Manchester Climate Monthly is going to take a closer look at each and every one of these 44 “actions.”
Twice a week, on “Annual Plan Tuesdays” and “Annual Plan Thursdays” we will be asking a few straightforward questions about each item. And to illustrate each post, we (Marc Hudson and Marc Roberts) are devising “Top Trump” cards for all of these actions. At two a week it will take you until December or so to collect the whole set… So far can’t give you a percentage on the 2005 figure, since the Council has been going off its 2009/10 baseline, in direct contradiction of its own plan.
And throughout all of this, we are asking YOU, the reader, and council tax payer (probably), what YOU think the Council should REALLY be doing… Because next year the council moves to a “three year plan.” And given what we already know of the low quality of the carbon plans and their implementation so far, we, the citizens, will be complicit if we remain silent…
4.21 Markets (10% of building emissions) will focus on New Smithfield Market this year where, subject to funding approvals, a new energy efficient fish market will be built to replace the old block and condition surveys will be completed on two other market blocks.
What was said last year (direct quote from 2012/13 plan)
5.2.4.3 Markets (11% of building emissions)
Low-carbon design principles will be embedded into the design of a new fish
market at New Smithfield Market (NSM), which will replace an older, inefficient,
market building.
NSM will also reduce energy consumption through the replacement of 7 over-
sized chlorifiers with water heaters, plus rewiring and roof replacement works.
NSM is also on the short-list, depending upon feasibility, to have a voltage
optimizer installed to further reduce energy use.
MCFly’s verdict
Besides the fact that THESE ARE RECYCLED PROMISES, you mean?
“subject to funding approvals”… “condition surveys” Hallelujuah! We’re saved!!! But seriously – is there any actual carbon saving here? No, just more ‘surveys’ – 4 years into a plan, and we have, as the sixth item in the “plan” just more “scoping.” Said it before, will say it again: What. Have. They. Been. Doing. These. Last. Three. Years??
What would a proper three year plan around this item look like? They would publish the energy and carbon information they have for ALL their markets. They would ask users of the market for ideas about what can be done. While doing
How can culture be shifted around this item? How about giving out executive summaries, in multiple languages, of the Climate Change Action Plan? Or employing a local cartoonist to make a cartoon guide to Climate Change and what local people can do about it?.
What else should the Council be doing around this item? Not making the same promise in consecutive years? Naughty bureaucrats!!
Other info n/a
Phone numbers and emails of the organisations
Email: info@wholesalemarket.co.uk
Telephone: 0161 234 5710
New Smithfield Wholesale Market
Whitworth Street East
Manchester
M11 2WJ

You are invited to a public debate on how we can meet the challenge of climate change – undoubtedly one of the major problems faced by our nation and the world.
There are complex technical, economic, social and political issues that bear on this and a panel of experts has been assembled from industry, local government and academia, whose knowledge covers all these aspects.
Representatives from The University of Manchester will include Professor Kevin Anderson, Director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change, and Dr David North, Director of the Centre of Sustainable Consumption.
Each panel member will give a short presentation and afterwards there will be a public question and answer session. Fracking, transport policy, the viability of carbon capture and storage and many other issues are up for discussion!
A reception will be held after the event in which discussion can continue to flow.
If you are interested in attending, please register online at:
cut and paste from here; http://www.staffnet.manchester.ac.uk/news/display/?id=10505
Before I breach their copyright and get a letter from Lord Gnome’s learned friends (I believe it’s Peter Carter Ruck these days, yes?), I should point out that it’s a fantastic publication, Ian Hislop is an Adonis and you can – and should – subscribe here.
Now, on with the theft;
From issue 1346
Six days ago MCFly wrote to Ms Berger asking for a comment. Other than the standard “Your email has been received, and will receive a response as soon as possible” there has been nowt back.
On Sunday we posted “Emotathons, a beginner’s guide”, which was page 5 of the latest Manchester Climate Monthly. This is a typically emollient and diplomatic survey* of the current state of social movement practice, namely the tendency to stage big events (marches/camps) that allow people to vent their anger/feel joy and solidarity. It suggested that there is perhaps the teensy-weeniest opportunity cost to this (a point taken up and expanded very well in the comments)
There have already been a couple of very useful comments (thanks!!) on this. It occurred to me that we all could apply our brains to how to move beyond “emotathons.”
Here’s one suggestion to get the ball rolling…
http://askfortheworld.net/2013/08/14/two-bits-of-paper-to-unlock-skills-and-knowledge/
In 2012 Manchester City Council aimed for a 10% reduction in its own emissions. In July 2013 it claimed a 7% reduction. It was able to do this because responsibility for traffic lights moved from its books. Looking at everything else (buildings, transport) emissions went … UP by 1.8%.
So, building on that extremely strong base, the Council’s bureaucrats have proposed a series of actions to help them hit a new “7%” target. You can see the complete list here. Manchester Climate Monthly is going to take a closer look at each and every one of these 44 “actions.”
Twice a week, on “Annual Plan Tuesdays” and “Annual Plan Thursdays” we will be asking a few straightforward questions about each item. And to illustrate each post, we (Marc Hudson and Marc Roberts) are devising “Top Trump” cards for all of these actions. At two a week it will take you until December or so to collect the whole set… So far can’t give you a percentage on the 2005 figure, since the Council has been going off its 2009/10 baseline, in direct contradiction of its own plan.
And throughout all of this, we are asking YOU, the reader, and council tax payer (probably), what YOU think the Council should REALLY be doing… Because next year the council moves to a “three year plan.” And given what we already know of the low quality of the carbon plans and their implementation so far, we, the citizens, will be complicit if we remain silent…
What it says
4.20 Leisure estate (39% of building emissions) will deliver savings through the Manchester Sport and Leisure Trust (MS<) and Serco partners. The Aquatics Centre will commission a study to identify energy efficient options for light replacement in the pool hall, install dry urinals and LEDs and sensors in locations throughout the site. Wythenshawe Forum will also continue their installation of LEDs, efficient pool lighting, and business cases for other works. MS< will commission energy audits in three of their major sites and deliver their wider Sustainability Action Plan. The new Beswick Leisure Centre will be delivered to BREEAM Excellent standards and low carbon credentials incorporated into future developments at Hough End and Levenshulme.
What was said last year (direct quote from 2012/13 plan)
4.5.3 Manchester Sport & Leisure Trust (MS<). MS< (an independent
Charitable Trust that manages leisure facilities throughout Manchester) introduced a
sustainability policy for staff and developed a low-carbon plan that will lead to
delivery of spend-to-save energy efficiency projects in 2012/13.
MCFly’s verdict
So they’re going to “commission a study” here and “make a business case” there. WHAT HAVE THEY BEEN *DOING* THESE LAST 3 YEARS? REALLY? Oh, and the “Sustainability Action Plan” last year – is not to be found on the MS< website. Does it exist even?
What would a proper three year plan around this item look like?
There would be actual numbers attached to each of these items, about how much carbon would be saved. These goals would be ambitious, not weaselly. There would be quarterly reports on what progress was and was not being made. Don’t hold your breathe…
How can culture be shifted around this item? Engage sports clubs. Maybe fly some of them off to Bangladesh to play football. No, wait…
What else should the Council be doing around this item?
Actually engage sports clubs. Guilt City and United into tidying up their own act but also get it into the programmes for matches etc etc. Buy lots of copies of “Climate Change for Football Fans.” (obviously don’t BUY it at Amazon…)
Other info n/a
Phone numbers and emails of the organisations n/a
Emotathons are the Events (marches, camps etc) at which we emote for hours/days. Don’t get me wrong – emotions are legitimate and vital in every sense. It’s just that by staging virtually nothing but emotathons we use up limited resources on, in my opinion, the wrong things…
What do you think?
via Feedingthe5000 facebook page
Calling all gleaners around Manchester, Preston and Lancashire! We’ve just discovered tonnes of cauliflowers going to waste! Next Thursday 15th we’ll be heading down to a farm near Preston to glean those tasty veg! All produce going to charities dealing with food poverty via our good friends FareShare.
Next Thursday 15th August, 10am-5pm (TBC). Join us on the farm for an great day out in the countryside, travel expenses paid from nearby (just ask us first).
Contact martin@feeding5k.org to volunteer or for more info – join the Glean Revolution!